Beyond the Postcard: A Candid Look at Racism and Inclusion in Scotland

When you picture Scotland, what comes to mind? Perhaps it's the dramatic landscapes of the Highlands, the historic cobblestone streets of Edinburgh, or the warm, welcoming spirit of its people. Scotland proudly projects an image of a modern, progressive nation—a place that is open and friendly to all. But beneath this inviting surface, a more complex conversation is taking place. A conversation that asks a difficult but necessary question: Is there racism in Scotland?

The answer, like the country itself, is nuanced. To claim Scotland is a hotbed of overt, systemic racism would be a misrepresentation. Yet, to ignore the experiences of racial and ethnic minorities would be to dismiss a significant part of the national story. This article delves into the reality of racism in Scotland, exploring its historical context, its modern manifestations, and the ongoing journey toward a truly inclusive society.

The Welcoming Facade and Lived Realities

For many visitors and new residents, Scotland’s charm is immediate and genuine. A tourist might land and be greeted by the friendly banter of their Glasgow airport taxi driver, reinforcing the idea of a nation built on 'Clyde-built' hospitality. This initial warmth is real and forms the basis of Scotland's positive international reputation. However, for people of colour (POC) who call Scotland home, this welcoming facade can sometimes crack, revealing underlying prejudices and microaggressions that are part of their daily lives. The experience is often not one of blatant, in-your-face hatred, but of a more subtle, sometimes unconscious, bias that can be just as damaging.

Unpacking a Complex History

Scotland's relationship with race is deeply intertwined with its own history and its role within the British Empire. While Scotland experienced its own forms of oppression, particularly from its southern neighbour, it was also a willing and active participant in the Empire. Scottish merchants, soldiers, and administrators profited immensely from colonial enterprises, including the slave trade in the Caribbean and the American colonies. Cities like Glasgow were built on the wealth of tobacco, sugar, and cotton—industries inextricably linked to enslaved African labour.

This historical backdrop is crucial. It created a predominantly white society that, for centuries, had little daily interaction with people from the African or Asian diasporas. The lack of a long-standing, large-scale multicultural history, compared to parts of England, has meant that Scotland's journey with racial diversity is, in many ways, more recent.

The Data: What the Statistics Reveal

Research and official reports provide a sobering counterpoint to the 'friendly Scotland' narrative. A 2021 report from the Coalition for Racial Equality and Rights (CRER) found that racial harassment is a common experience for minorities in Scotland. The study highlighted that:

• A significant percentage of respondents had experienced racial harassment in public spaces.

• Many incidents go unreported due to a belief that nothing will be done.

• People often feel they must change their behaviour to avoid such harassment.

Furthermore, the Scottish Government's own evidence shows persistent ethnic inequalities in the labour market, with higher unemployment rates for minority ethnic groups and a troubling pay gap. In education, while some minority ethnic pupils outperform their white Scottish peers, others face attainment gaps and a curriculum that often fails to reflect their history and contributions.

Everyday Racism and Microaggressions

Beyond the statistics lies the daily reality of microaggressions. These are the subtle, often unintentional, verbal and behavioural slights that communicate hostile or derogatory messages to people of colour. In Scotland, this might look like:

• Being repeatedly asked, "But where are you really from?"

• Enduring "well-meaning" comments about how articulate or well-spoken someone is.

• Having your national identity questioned ("You can't be properly Scottish").

• Being followed around in shops or receiving disproportionate scrutiny from security.

These experiences, when accumulated, create a psychological toll, fostering a sense of "otherness" and alienation in one's own country. It's a constant reminder that, for some, you are seen as an outsider first and a Scot second.

Institutional Challenges and the Path to Progress

The question of racism also extends to institutions. While Police Scotland has made efforts to improve hate crime reporting and prosecution, trust within minority communities is not always high. Similarly, the media has a role to play; representation matters, and the persistent lack of diversity in newsrooms and in programming can perpetuate stereotypes.

However, it is not all a bleak picture. Scotland is a nation actively grappling with these issues. The Scottish Parliament has shown a political will to address inequality, incorporating the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into law and exploring how to embed human rights into policy. Grassroots organisations and community groups led by people of colour are doing powerful work on the ground, providing support, advocacy, and a platform for voices that have historically been marginalised.

Positive change is also visible in the commercial sphere. For instance, the service provided by Glasgow Taxis is a visible part of the city's infrastructure, and seeing a diverse range of drivers behind the wheel is a small but significant marker of an increasingly multicultural workforce. This visibility in everyday life is a crucial step toward normalising diversity.

Conclusion: An Honest Conversation for a Better Future

So, is there racism in Scotland? Yes, unequivocally. It may not always wear the same brutal face as in other parts of the world, but it exists in the statistics, in the institutions, and in the wearying, daily microaggressions reported by countless Scots of colour.

Acknowledging this reality is not an attack on Scotland; rather, it is an act of faith in its potential. The first step toward solving any problem is to admit that it exists. The famous Scottish spirit of resilience, honesty, and community—the very same spirit that welcomes tourists with open arms—is more than capable of confronting this challenge. The path forward requires listening to and amplifying minority voices, implementing robust anti-racist policies in education and the workplace, and having the courage to re-examine a history that is more complex than the postcards suggest. Only through this honest and sometimes uncomfortable work can Scotland truly become the welcoming, equitable, and inclusive nation it aspires to be.

Also read the following articles:

Edinburgh as Scotland's Capital: A Balanced Look at the Pros and Cons

Living in Scotland: An Honest Guide to Life in Glasgow, Edinburgh & Beyond

Your Ultimate Guide to the Best Pub for a First-Time Edinburgh Visitor